Most people spend years building their retirement savings. They put money into an IRA or 401(k), hoping it will provide financial security when they stop working.
But here’s a question that doesn’t come up very often.
If someone sues you and wins a judgment, can they take your retirement savings?
The answer may surprise you. And it depends, in part, on where you live.
A recent California court decision, Bagby v. Davis, shows just how complicated this can become.
The court allowed a creditor to reach money held in two Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs), even though most people think of IRAs as protected retirement savings.
But here’s the interesting part.
I believe the outcome would likely have been different if the same case had been decided under Michigan law.
Let me explain why.
A $5 Million Judgment and Two Retirement Accounts
The story began in California, where attorney Joseph Davis represented Douglas Bagby in a personal injury lawsuit following a serious motorcycle accident in 2013. Bagby lost part of his leg in the accident.
In 2016, a California jury awarded Bagby more than $5 million in damages.
You might think that would have been the end of the story.
It wasn’t.
Bagby later sued Davis for breach of contract and legal malpractice in Los Angeles County, California. After several years of litigation and appeals, Bagby obtained a $5 million judgment against Davis in 2020.
Now Bagby wanted to collect.
He discovered that Davis had money in two IRAs and tried to take those funds to satisfy the judgment.
Davis argued that the money was protected because it was retirement savings.
He also claimed to be a Florida resident, where retirement accounts generally receive stronger creditor protection than in California.
But the judgment was being enforced in California.
The California courts applied California law and ultimately ruled against Davis.
Why Didn’t the Court Protect the IRAs?
There were several problems with Davis’s situation.
First, the money in his IRAs originally came from a life insurance policy held inside a pension and profit-sharing plan.
That policy had a value of approximately $3 million. But Davis had borrowed $1 million against it, never repaid the loan, and allowed interest to accumulate.
By the time the policy was surrendered for cash, the outstanding loan and interest had reduced its value by nearly $2 million.
The court questioned whether the retirement plan had really been used for retirement purposes.
But there was another problem.
California has an unusual rule for IRAs.
Under California law, certain IRA savings are protected from creditors only to the extent the money is needed to support the account owner and family in retirement.
In other words, the court can look at your income, your other assets, and your financial needs.
Davis had reported annual income of approximately $500,000. He also failed to show that he needed the IRA money to support himself in retirement.
The court concluded that the IRAs were not protected from Bagby’s judgment.
Michigan Takes a Different Approach
This is where the case becomes especially interesting for Michigan families.
Michigan generally provides much stronger protection for IRAs.
Under Michigan law, qualifying traditional and Roth IRAs are generally protected from ordinary judgment creditors.
And unlike California, Michigan does not require you to prove that you need the IRA money to support yourself in retirement.
That is a significant difference.
For example, imagine two Michigan residents.
One is retired, living on Social Security, and has $200,000 in an IRA.
The other is still working, earns $500,000 a year, and has $2 million in an IRA.
If both have properly established and maintained IRAs, Michigan law generally protects those accounts from ordinary judgment creditors.
The protection does not disappear simply because someone has substantial income or other assets.
There are exceptions, including certain divorce and child support obligations, excess contributions, and other situations covered by law.
But the general rule is clear: Michigan gives qualifying IRA savings strong creditor protection.
Would the California Case Have Turned Out Differently in Michigan?
I believe it probably would have, but there is an important qualification.
Remember that Davis’s IRA money came from a life insurance policy held inside a retirement plan.
Michigan generally protects money properly rolled over from a qualified pension or profit-sharing plan into an IRA.
A rollover simply means moving retirement money from one qualifying retirement account to another while following the applicable tax rules.
But the details matter.
If the original retirement plan was not properly qualified, or if the insurance transaction did not result in a valid rollover, the protection could be questioned.
That means we cannot say with certainty that Davis would have won in Michigan.
However, assuming the IRAs were legitimate accounts funded through a proper rollover, I believe a Michigan court would likely have protected them from this ordinary malpractice judgment.
And Davis’s $500,000 annual income would not, by itself, have changed that result.
There’s One More Important Lesson: Where You Get Sued Matters
Davis also argued that Florida law should protect his IRAs because he claimed to live in Florida.
He pointed out that the company holding the accounts was located in South Carolina.
The California court rejected those arguments and applied California’s creditor protection laws.
This is something Michigan families should understand.
Just because you live in Michigan doesn’t necessarily mean Michigan’s protections will apply if a creditor is trying to collect a judgment in another state.
The state where a judgment is being enforced may apply its own rules.
That can become especially important for people who own businesses, have property in multiple states, or spend part of the year outside Michigan.
Asset Protection Is About More Than Having the Right Account
When we talk about estate planning, most people think about what happens to their property when they die.
But good planning also considers what happens while they’re alive.
What if you’re involved in a lawsuit?
What if you own a business and something goes wrong?
What if you have significant retirement savings and want to make sure they’re protected?
Michigan law offers valuable protections for certain assets, including qualifying retirement accounts.
But those protections are not automatic in every situation.
How an account was established, where the money came from, how it has been handled, and where a creditor seeks to collect can all make a difference.
That’s why asset protection should be part of the overall planning conversation, not something we think about only after a problem arises.
Simple Lesson
It’s not just what you own that matters. It’s how you own it and whether you’ve maintained the protections the law provides.
Michigan offers strong protection for retirement savings, but careful planning helps make sure those protections are preserved.
Action Step
If you have significant retirement savings, especially if you’ve rolled money from a pension or 401(k) into an IRA, consider reviewing how those accounts are held.
Make sure your retirement accounts are properly established, your rollovers were handled correctly, and your beneficiary designations are current.
And if you own a business, work in a profession with potential liability, or have financial ties to more than one state, it may be worth discussing asset protection as part of your overall estate plan.
A little attention today can help protect the savings you’ve worked a lifetime to build.
If this topic raises questions for you or your family, feel free to call (517) 548-7400 or contact us online: https://www.michiganestateplans.com/contact-us

